Taelvix
HomeGEO servicesSample auditPricingBlogAboutFAQFree pilot
Menu
HomeGEO servicesSample auditPricingBlogAboutFAQFree pilot
Home / Blog / ChatGPT vs Gemini vs AI Overviews

ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews give different answers to the same local question

Research · By Aashir Abdullah, founder of Taelvix · 20 November 2026

On 17 November 2026 we asked ChatGPT, Google Gemini and Google AI Overviews the same four questions about dental practices in one Texas city. Between them they named more than 30 different practices. On two of the four questions, not a single practice was named by all three, and on the other two only one was. A business that checks just one AI platform sees only part of the picture.

The test

This was part of our sample audit of a dental practice in a Texas city, which we keep anonymous. We asked four questions a customer might ask, each once, in a fresh session on each platform, with the city and state included. We recorded every business each platform named.

What each platform named

QuestionChatGPT namedGemini namedAI Overviews namedNamed by all three
What is the best family dentist in [City], Texas?5531
Who are the top-rated dentists in [City], Texas?10541
Where is the best place to get dental implants in [City], Texas?3530
I need an emergency dentist in [City], Texas today. Who should I call?4520

Three patterns stood out.

The lists had little in common

For the emergency question, the three platforms named 11 practices between them and no practice appeared in more than one answer. For the implants question, ChatGPT recommended three specialist implant and oral surgery practices, and Google AI Overviews named three practices with no overlap with ChatGPT's list.

The answers were different lengths

Gemini named five practices for every question. ChatGPT named between three and ten. Google AI Overviews named two to four. A business can be fifth on Gemini and still be absent from a two-name AI Overview.

Each platform leaned on different sources

Gemini's answers came with Google Maps listings. ChatGPT cited a ranking site, a review platform and practice websites. When we asked about the audited practice by name, Google's AI Overview cited a review site and the practice's own pages, and repeated opening hours that were wrong.

What this means for agencies

  • Test all three platforms. A client that looks fine in ChatGPT may be missing from AI Overviews, which appear inside ordinary Google searches.
  • Fix the sources, not just the website. Google Maps and Business Profile data seem to matter for Gemini; third-party ranking and review sites seem to matter for ChatGPT. Work on both.
  • Report position, not just presence. Being fifth in a five-name list and absent from a two-name list are different problems.
  • Re-test over time. These answers are from one day. Monthly re-tests show whether the work is moving the numbers.

This is why every Taelvix GEO audit tests ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews side by side, and why our white-label GEO services report results per platform.

Questions agencies ask

Which AI platform matters most for a local business?

There is no single answer, because customers use all three and each names different businesses. Google AI Overviews appear inside ordinary Google searches, Gemini is built into Google's products, and ChatGPT is used directly. That is why our audits test all three rather than one.

Why do ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews disagree?

They draw on different sources. In our test, Gemini's answers came with Google Maps listings, while ChatGPT cited a ranking site, a review platform and business websites. Different sources produce different shortlists.

Is this test large enough to generalise from?

No. It is one city, one day and one run of each question. It shows that the platforms can disagree sharply, not how often they do. We publish the method so others can repeat it.

Check one of your clients for free

Send us one client and we'll test them on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews, then send you a one-page, white-label report with the three fixes that matter most, within 2 business days. No charge, and we never contact your client.

Request a free pilot

Related reading

  • Why ChatGPT recommends some local businesses and not others
  • What a GEO audit checks, and how the score is worked out
  • Sample AI visibility audit for a dental practice
  • GEO vs SEO: what changes when the answer comes from AI

Be the answer.

White-label GEO and AEO for marketing agencies · Kolkata, India

contact@taelvix.com

© 2026 Taelvix

HomeGEO servicesSample auditPricingBlogAboutLinkedInPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service